| Team | Name | Pos. | Cl. |
|---|---|---|---|
| Team: West Texas A&M | Nick Andress | Pos.: WR | Cl.: 2015 |
| Team: Southwest Baptist University | Christian Bedford | Pos.: DL | Cl.: 2014 |
| Team: Southwest Baptist University | Dayne Bullock | Pos.: OL | Cl.: 2013 |
| Team: Southwestern Oklahoma | Brad Butler | Pos.: NA | Cl.: 2001 |
| Team: Saint Vincent (PA) | Joseph Coomaraswamy | Pos.: DL | Cl.: 2018 |
| Team: Texas State | Fritz Cox | Pos.: NA | Cl.: 1989 |
| Team: Texas State | Zach Crawford | Pos.: OL | Cl.: 2010 |
| Team: Texas Lutheran | Riley Dale | Pos.: OL | Cl.: 2018 |
| Team: Mary Hardin Baylor | Jaleel Davis | Pos.: LB | Cl.: 2019 |
| Team: Texas | Greg Dolan | Pos.: OL | Cl.: 2003 |
| Team: Northwestern | David Farman | Pos.: TE | Cl.: 1998 |
| Team: St Francis, University of Houston | Bear Fenimore | Pos.: QB | Cl.: 2012 |
| Team: Texas A&M | Alex Freeman | Pos.: DS | Cl.: 2012 |
| Team: Georgia Tech | Michael Garlow | Pos.: RB | Cl.: 1998 |
| Team: Rice | Parker Hanusa | Pos.: DE | Cl.: 2013 |
| Team: Incarnate Word | Sean Hoeferkamp | Pos.: DB | Cl.: 2013 |
| Team: Tyler Junior College | Justin Jackson | Pos.: NA | Cl.: 1999 |
| Team: Glenville State | Ryan Jannak | Pos.: LB | Cl.: 2005 |
| Team: Texas, MLB- (Rockies, Royals) | Ben Johnson | Pos.: QB | Cl.: 2012 |
| Team: Iowa | David Kerr | Pos.: DE | Cl.: 1984 |
| Team: Colorado School Of Mines | Danny Lackowski | Pos.: OL | Cl.: 2019 |
| Team: Air Force Academy | Jonathan Lattimore | Pos.: DB | Cl.: 2002 |
| Team: Northern Arizona | RJ Martinez | Pos.: QB | Cl.: 2021 |
| Team: Texas, NFL- (Lions) | Will Matthews | Pos.: RB | Cl.: 1999 |
| Team: Wheaton | Andy McClain | Pos.: WR | Cl.: 2005 |
| Team: Fresno State | Collin McGuire | Pos.: K | Cl.: 2012 |
| Team: University of Houston | Jason Mckinley | Pos.: QB | Cl.: 1995 |
| Team: Texas | Mac Mcwhorter | Pos.: TE | Cl.: 2005 |
| Team: Texas | Dustin Miksch | Pos.: WR | Cl.: 2002 |
| Team: Maryland | Brendan Moore | Pos.: OL | Cl.: 2013 |
| Team: Texas | Mark Murdock | Pos.: QB | Cl.: 1987 |
| Team: Mary Hardin Baylor | Jaikem Murphy | Pos.: RB | Cl.: 2018 |
| Team: Lamar University | Shiloh Newman | Pos.: | Cl.: 1989 |
| Team: Texas | Troy Reimer | Pos.: OL | Cl.: 1989 |
| Team: Hardin-Simmons | Glenn Revell | Pos.: OL | Cl.: 2005 |
| Team: Oklahoma State | Jason Ricks | Pos.: K | Cl.: 2004 |
| Team: Howard Payne | Cooper Rogers | Pos.: TE | Cl.: 2000 |
| Team: North Texas | Chad Rose | Pos.: OL | Cl.: 2003 |
| Team: Texas A&M, NFL- (Colts, Saints, Bears) | Lance Teichelman | Pos.: DL | Cl.: 1989 |
| Team: Wake Forrest, NFL- (Chargers) | Brad Watson | Pos.: DB | Cl.: 2013 |
| Team: Iowa Wesleyan | EJ Wiley | Pos.: DE | Cl.: 2021 |
| Team: Texas, NFL- (Packers, Cardinals, Bengals, Falcons) | Marcus Wilkins | Pos.: LB | Cl.: 1998 |
| Team: Stanford | Jordan Williamson | Pos.: K | Cl.: 2009 |